Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Shneyer Nison al-Podoli's avatar

Very nice summary of the main palestinian fallacies. But I also want to put forward a point regarding Y2619. What about the netinim hypothesis? Why rely on the idea of magi if we have historical evidence that Mesopotamian/Iranian origin slaves owned by early Babylonian-exile Jews were integrated into the Levite order at the beginning of the second temple period due to the very small Israelite population who persisted in identifying as Levites?

Expand full comment
JohnTrain's avatar

You should have included the PCA which shows Christian and Roman Levantines being more AnatolianAegean (very probable this is real) and then a backshift into BA Levant for Palis because of excess Peninsular + Egyptian, I think it would have drive the point home, but overall very good post

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts